Menu
English

Why an Important Scene with Sam and Galadriel was Removed from 'The Lord of the Rings'?

Still from the film 'The Lord of the Rings'

The franchise would have become much darker, although it would seem there was room for more.

The Lord of the Rings film trilogy has its share of epic moments, but many of the books were left behind the scenes. For example, the scene where Sam looks into Galadriel's Mirror and sees frightening images of the future. Peter Jackson decided not to include the episode in his "magnum opus", and for good reason, because it is a real spoiler, revealing almost the entire third act of the story.

What did Sam see in the Mirror?

In the book, Galadriel invites Sam to look into her magic mirror, which shows "what was, is, and can happen." And good-natured Sam with, who at first only wanted to spy on how things are going in the Shire, suddenly gets a powerful kick from fate.

First, the image of Frodo appears before him, pale, exhausted, lying somewhere near a cliff. Then he sees himself wandering along a dark corridor (most likely, these are the tunnels of Cirith Ungol). And then, the native Shire, but no longer cozy and green, but devastated: trees are falling, the mill is demolished, and in its place a brick factory is smoking.

LOTR still

This is the "Scouring of the Shire" , an episode that was not shown in the film at all, but in the book it became the final test for the hobbits.

Why is this not in the film?

Peter Jackson has already gone all out with three-hour films, adding Sam's prophecies would have been too much. Especially since the audience would have immediately understood that:

  • Frodo would almost die on the way to Mordor;
  • that Sam would have to carry the Ring instead of him;
  • that the Shire would face a catastrophe in the finale.

It turns out that Jackson simply spared us from premature discoveries. After all, it is much more interesting to follow the story when the future of the heroes remains a mystery.

7 Amazing Book Characters from 'The Lord of the Rings' Who Never Made It to the Screen — But Jackson Can Be Forgiven 7 Amazing Book Characters from 'The Lord of the Rings' Who Never Made It to the Screen — But Jackson Can Be Forgiven Read more 12 April 2025
Rose Drowned in a Pool, and King Kong was 45 cm Tall: Here are the Tricks That Viewers Don’t Notice, But Directors Actively Use Rose Drowned in a Pool, and King Kong was 45 cm Tall: Here are the Tricks That Viewers Don’t Notice, But Directors Actively Use Read more 12 April 2025
Why Gandalf Sees Power in Hobbits in 'The Lord of the Rings', Did He Know Their Fate? The Truth Runs Deeper Than the Films Why Gandalf Sees Power in Hobbits in 'The Lord of the Rings', Did He Know Their Fate? The Truth Runs Deeper Than the Films Read more 15 April 2025
Only 5 'Black Mirror' Episodes Have an 8.5+ IMDb Rating — and the 'Pig One' Isn’t Even Close Only 5 'Black Mirror' Episodes Have an 8.5+ IMDb Rating — and the 'Pig One' Isn’t Even Close Read more 16 April 2025
400 Cookies in 3 Days: How 'Squid Game' Brought Dalgona to Life and Why It was Made on Set 400 Cookies in 3 Days: How 'Squid Game' Brought Dalgona to Life and Why It was Made on Set Read more 16 April 2025
What 'The Yellow King' Mean in 'True Detective': Not All Fans Solved This Mystery What 'The Yellow King' Mean in 'True Detective': Not All Fans Solved This Mystery Read more 15 April 2025
Fan Theories Confirmed: Here's How the New 'Lazarus' is Connected to the Cult Classic 'Cowboy Bebop' Fan Theories Confirmed: Here's How the New 'Lazarus' is Connected to the Cult Classic 'Cowboy Bebop' Read more 15 April 2025
New 'Dune' Version Earns 23 Times More Than Original: These Remakes Have Brought Hollywood Millions New 'Dune' Version Earns 23 Times More Than Original: These Remakes Have Brought Hollywood Millions Read more 14 April 2025
In 'The Lord of the Rings', Arwen Gave Up Immortality Not Just for Love: Here’s Why the Elf Chose to Become Mortal In 'The Lord of the Rings', Arwen Gave Up Immortality Not Just for Love: Here’s Why the Elf Chose to Become Mortal Read more 14 April 2025
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Read more