Wes Anderson’s latest, The Phoenician Scheme, is turning heads — and stirring debate. With a solid 76% Fresh score on Rotten Tomatoes from 83 critics, the film’s trademark visual charm and quirky humor win many over, but some feel the substance doesn’t quite match the style.
Brian Viner of the Daily Mail praises the film as "consistently lovely on the eye" with a "terrific, genuinely funny opening," though he admits it "careers downhill thereafter." Laura Clifford at Reeling Reviews is enthusiastic, highlighting the inspired addition of Michael Cera and Benedict Cumberbatch’s wild turn as a Rasputin-like figure. Meanwhile, Aaron Neuwirth from We Live Entertainment calls it an "adventure lark" with sharp humor — and notes that Benicio del Toro gets to flex his acting chops more than usual.
But not all are convinced. Sarah Manvel of Movies We Texted About gives the film a thumbs down, describing it as "enjoyable while it’s happening" but "the first misfire on Mr. Anderson’s resume," where style "doesn’t hold up" without deeper substance. Brian Eggert from Deep Focus Review echoes this mixed sentiment, admiring Anderson’s precision but feeling the emotional connection to lead character Zsa-zsa Korda is limited.
So, what’s the fuss about? Set in the fictional 1950s nation of Phoenicia, the story centers on wealthy tycoon Zsa-zsa Korda (Benicio del Toro), who, after surviving assassination attempts, enlists the help of his estranged daughter Sister Liesl (Mia Threapleton), a nun in training. Against a backdrop of political chaos and family drama, the film navigates themes of power, loyalty, and redemption.
The Phoenician Scheme premiered at Cannes 2025 and hits U.S. theaters May 30.
